case study meaning in engineering

• U of T Home
• Faculty Home

Engineering Communication Program

Case Studies

Case studies occur frequently in engineering because, by nature, engineering analyzes (studies) situations that already exist (cases). This document explains how to use a basic engineering problem-solving method to structure case studies, but the structure may also apply to other engineering reports (including undergraduate theses). This document focuses on a particular logical structure that is important to engineering. (For format, see Type of Documents / Short Reports ) Michael Jordan (not the basketball player) describes the basics of the problem-solving method this way:

• Understanding the situation being faced;
• Analyzing the specific problem to be tackled;
• Creating, analyzing, and refining a solution;
• And further evaluating, improving, and implementing. [1]

The method is known as: Situation — Problem — Solution(s) — Evaluation

Each of the logical components here consists more of questions than “how-to” because the goal of this web page is to help you think through the logic structure of this pattern.

1. Situation: Even when a client (or professor) defines a situation, engineers need to understand it in their own terms:

• What are the needs of the client?
• What are the constraints of the situation (time, resources, laws, technology)?
• What are the background facts?
• What are the key questions that need asking?

Example: What happens when the Client doesn’t tell you everything?

If an engineer responding to the Request for Proposal (RFP) below did not think through the whole situation, she might end up in big trouble. An RFP asks contractors to bid on a particular project. Getting the job without understanding the situation can be disastrous. This RFP describes the government’s responsibilities in a research project to test ABS brakes using an “instrumented car” (a car outfitted with sophisticated measuring equipment):

An instrumented vehicle, Pontiac 6000 STE, has been developed and will be provided to the contractor without charge by Transport Canada . A separate contractor has been engaged to perform hardware modifications to the various systems in the vehicle if they are required and approved by the scientific authority. Costs associated with any approved modifications, and the maintenance of the data collection system will be the responsibility of Transport Canada , unless the contractor has been negligent in the use of the system. [2]

All of this sounds good at first–someone else is worrying about maintaining the systems inside a rather expensive vehicle–BUT what about systems outside the vehicle? Such things as pop-up stop signs and means of altering the slipperiness of the track will be needed. Since these are outside the car, who pays? If those bidding on this contract do not state their understanding of the situation clearly, they could win a bid but lose a bundle. Showing a clear understanding of the situation is the first step to a clear report.

Where it fits: Typically this will fit into the introduction or background sections of a report.

2. Problem: Before you can solve a problem you need to know what it is. Defining a Problem clearly is crucial to finding a solution. In defining the problem, you need to explain the factors that affect the problem. Consider not only what the client says the problem is, but what the client might not recognize. Here is a statement of a problem, taken from an assignment in MIE 561S, Health Care Systems:

Sunnybrook’s Chronic Pain Clinic experiences two problems:

• In its present mode of operation, it loses money on initial consultations.
• Patients’ waiting times for initial consultations are perceived as being too long and should be shortened without significant expenditure.

Unless the number of consultations can be increased by 15% using the same resources, the pain clinic is in danger of being shut down.

This problem statement is not complete. In fact, it is the problem as defined by the client, which is really just the situation. The writer needs to analyze the problem: the problem here might in part be defined as inefficiency in initial consultations.

Sunnybrook’s Chronic Pain Clinic loses money on initial consultations and suffers from long patient waiting times for initial consultations. Unless the number of consultations can be increased by 15% using the same resources, the pain clinic is in danger of being shut down. The loss of money and the waiting times are related because two of the four doctors do not manage to see their patients within the allotted one hour consultation. This means not only that these doctors are unable to see as many patients as the other two doctors, but that those they do see have to wait well past their scheduled appointment. The problem, then, is to eliminate inefficiency in initial consultations without compromising the level offer.

Part of defining the problem is seeing it in terms of what has been done before. These questions might help you explain the full background to the problem:

• What are the parameters that have been set for your analysis?
• What is happening in the situation now?
• What are the shortcomings of the current or previous ways of handling the situation?
• What changes have been made in the situation? or are expected?

These questions might lead to an additional paragraph in our example to clarify and refine the definition of the problem. Here the writer goes on to consider how one parameter physicians’ financial benefit might affect the current situation.

(cont’d from above example)

If inefficiency is a factor, understanding the physicians’ relationship to the clinic becomes important. First, financially, the four doctors who provide service in the pain clinic do so out of interest in the field. They derive little financial benefit from their involvement; in fact, they incur a significant opportunity cost for not performing other, more lucrative procedures. Their pay is not proportionally dependent on the number of patients they examine; instead, it is a percentage of the total revenue generated by a pool of twenty-six physicians performing a variety of roles at the hospital. For this reason, personal income cannot influence physician behavior.

This example is only part of what goes into a problem definition, but it shows how the writer can refine his problem definition by limiting the possible parameters for solutions.

Where it fits: Typically, the Problem definition is also the purpose of the report; therefore, it will follow the situation, or sometimes, precede it. Notice that the problem and the situation overlap. This is predictable because the problem arises out of the situation.

3. Solution: University assignments often expect you to come up with alternatives; hence, you may need to examine more than one solution. Ultimately, to be effective, any solution must:

• Solve the problem. Obvious, but explain: How does the solution work?
• Explain how the solution can be derived from the available data. How does it fit with what we know?
• Fit clearly into the available research on a topic. What research supports it?

As you might guess, this section could be a huge part of the body of a report.

4. Evaluation: Before engineers can implement a solution, it needs to be refined. The first step in refining any solution is an evaluation. You need to think your way around the solution just as if it were an object you were walking around. Ask as many questions as possible. Here are a few:

• Is the solution you suggest likely to be successful?
• What limitations might prevent total success? (eg. does it depend on people being trained?)
• What must a company do to make your solution work? (funding? training? design? safety measures?)
• If you are proposing more than one solution, which one(s) do you recommend be implemented? In which order? (short term vs. long term; most important vs. less important; necessary vs. optional)

Where it fits: Typically, the evaluation comes just before the recommendations. Once you have evaluated several options, then you can make a recommendation. It may also be incorporated into the recommendations.

References:

[1] Jordan, Michael P. 1988. “How can problem-solution structures help writers plan and write technical documents?” Solving Problems in Technical Writing. Ed. Lynne Beene and Peter White. Toronto: Oxford. [2] Supply and Services Canada . 1989. RFP 045SZ.T8080-9-4780/B.

© 2024 Faculty of Applied Science and Engineering

• Accessibility
• Student Data Practices
• Website Feedback

All Subjects

Intro to Engineering

Study guides for every class, that actually explain what's on your next test, case studies, from class:.

Case studies are in-depth investigations of a particular instance or example, often used to analyze real-life applications of concepts, theories, or practices. They provide valuable insights by examining the complexities and nuances of specific situations, making them an essential tool in understanding material selection and design considerations. By exploring the successes and challenges faced in various projects, case studies help inform better decision-making in engineering practices.

congrats on reading the definition of Case Studies . now let's actually learn it.

5 Must Know Facts For Your Next Test

• Case studies often involve real-world examples that highlight the decision-making process regarding material selection and design considerations.
• They can demonstrate the impact of different materials on the performance and durability of a product over its lifecycle.
• Case studies may reveal common challenges faced in engineering projects, such as cost constraints, regulatory requirements, or sustainability issues.
• Through case studies, engineers can learn from previous projects to avoid repeating mistakes and improve future designs.
• Analyzing case studies helps engineers understand the importance of interdisciplinary collaboration in successful material selection and design.

Review Questions

• Case studies enhance understanding by providing real-life examples that illustrate the complexities of material selection and design. They allow students to see how theoretical concepts are applied in practice and the consequences of different choices. By analyzing various cases, students can grasp how factors like cost, performance, and sustainability impact engineering decisions.
• Successful case studies often highlight key lessons such as the importance of thorough research on material properties and potential challenges. They demonstrate how engineers navigated obstacles like budget constraints or regulatory hurdles while achieving their goals. Learning from these experiences helps future engineers anticipate similar issues in their own projects.
• Case studies play a crucial role in shaping ethical practices by showcasing the consequences of poor decision-making in material selection and design. They reveal how choices can impact safety, environmental sustainability, and social responsibility. Analyzing these instances encourages engineers to prioritize ethical considerations, leading to more responsible innovations that reflect societal values.

Related terms

Material Properties : The characteristics of materials that determine their behavior under various conditions, including strength, elasticity, and durability.

Design Optimization : The process of adjusting design parameters to achieve the best performance, efficiency, or cost-effectiveness in a product or system.

Engineering Ethics : The moral principles and standards that guide engineers in their professional conduct and decision-making processes.

" Case Studies " also found in:

Subjects ( 231 ).

• AP Psychology
• Abnormal Psychology
• Additive Manufacturing and 3D Printing
• Adolescent Development
• Advanced Communication Research Methods
• Advanced Design Strategy and Software
• Advanced Legal Research
• Advanced Media Writing
• Advanced Public Speaking
• Advertising Copywriting
• Africa Since 1800
• American Society
• Anthropology of Food
• Anthropology of Globalization
• Applied Impact Evaluation
• Art Direction
• Art Theory and Criticism
• Art Therapy
• Art and Meditation
• Art and Neuroscience
• Art and Social Justice
• Art and Trauma Studies
• Behavioral and Social Sciences in Public Health
• Bilingualism in History
• Biologically Inspired Robotics
• Biomedical Engineering I
• Brand Experience Marketing
• Brand Management and Strategy
• Business Anthropology
• Business Economics
• Business Ethics in Nanotechnology
• Business Ethics in the Digital Age
• Business Fundamentals for Public Relations
• Business Incubation and Acceleration
• Business Networking
• Business Semiotics
• Business Storytelling
• Business and Economics Reporting
• Causes and Prevention of Violence
• Classroom Management
• Coastal Resilience Engineering
• Cognitive Bias in Business Decision Making
• Cognitive Computing in Business
• Communication Research Methods
• Communication and Popular Culture
• Communication for Leaders
• Comparative Criminal Justice Systems
• Contemporary Social Policy
• Corporate Communication
• Corporate Sustainability Reporting
• Courts and Society
• Creative Producing II
• Crime and Human Development
• Criminal Justice
• Criminology
• Crisis Management and Communication
• Critical Native American Legal and Policy Studies
• Critical Thinking
• Cross-Cultural Management
• Curatorial Studies
• Curriculum Development
• Customer Experience Management
• Cybersecurity for Business
• Data Visualization for Business
• Design Strategy and Software I
• Design and Interactive Experiences
• Developmental Psychology
• Deviance and Social Control
• Digital Art Preservation
• Digital Media Art
• Documentary Production
• Economic Development
• Economic Geography
• Editorial Design
• Education Policy and Reform
• Education in American Culture
• Educational Leadership
• Educational Psychology
• English and Language Arts Education
• Environmental Biology
• Ethical Supply Chain Management
• Ethics in Accounting
• Ethics in Accounting and Finance
• Ethnic Studies
• Feature Writing
• Film Industry
• Foundations of Education
• Fundamentals of Creative Development
• Gamification in Business
• Gender in Modern American History
• Gender, Sexuality, and Race in Global Political Issues
• Global Media
• Global Perspectives on Identity and Diversity
• Global Studies
• Globalization and International Political Economy
• Governmental Public Affairs
• Green Manufacturing Processes
• Health Campaigns
• History of Education
• Holistic and Complementary Approaches to Health and Healing
• Human Behavior in the Social Environment I
• Human Sexuality
• Improvisational Leadership
• Indians Overseas – A Global View
• Indigenous Issues Across the Americas
• Indigenous Peoples and Environmental Change in the North American West
• Installation Art
• Intelligent Transportation Systems
• Interactive Marketing Strategy
• Interest Groups, Social Movements, and Public Policy
• International Business Negotiations
• International Development and Sustainability
• International Economics
• International Public Relations
• Intro to Business
• Intro to Political Science
• Intro to Psychology
• Introduction to Brain and Behavior
• Introduction to Cognitive Science
• Introduction to Communication Writing
• Introduction to Community Psychology
• Introduction to Comparative Politics
• Introduction to Cultural Anthropology
• Introduction to Demographic Methods
• Introduction to Education
• Introduction to Ethnic Studies
• Introduction to Gender Studies
• Introduction to Hospitality and Tourism
• Introduction to Human Sexuality
• Introduction to Humanities
• Introduction to Journalism
• Introduction to Music
• Introduction to Political Communications
• Introduction to Political Research
• Introduction to Political Sociology
• Introduction to Public Policy
• Introduction to Public Speaking
• Introduction to Social Media
• Introduction to Women's Studies
• Journalism Research
• Language and Culture
• Latin America, 1791-Present
• Latin American Politics
• Leadership Communication
• Lifecycle Nutrition
• Lighting Design for Stage
• Line Producing
• London Museums
• Magazine Writing and Editing
• Market Research: Tools and Techniques for Data Collection and Analysis
• Mass Media and Society
• Mathematics Education
• Media Criticism
• Media Expression and Communication
• Media Strategy
• Media and Politics
• Multimedia Reporting
• Music Psychology
• Music of the Modern Era
• Narrative Documentary Production
• Native People and Their Environment
• Negotiation and Conflict Resolution
• Neuroprosthetics
• Newswriting
• Organization Design
• Organizations and Public Policy
• Philosophy of Education
• Philosophy of Law
• Photojournalism I
• Physiology of Motivated Behaviors
• Police and Society
• Political Campaigns
• Political Economy of International Relations
• Political Geography
• Population and Society
• Power and Politics in Organizations
• Principles and Practice of Public Relations
• Production Design
• Production II
• Production III
• Professional Presentation
• Professional Selling
• Professionalism and Research in Nursing
• Psychology of Economic Decision-Making
• Psychology of Language
• Public Art and Urban Design
• Public Policy Analysis
• Public Relations Ethics
• Public Relations in Nonprofit Settings
• Quantum Leadership
• Radio Station Management
• Religion and Psychology
• Religions of the West
• Reporting in Depth
• Robotics and Bioinspired Systems
• Science Education
• Set Design for Theater and Film
• Social Problems and Public Policy
• Social Stratification
• Social Studies Education
• Sociology of Education
• Sociology of Marriage and the Family
• Sociology of Religion
• Sports Psychology
• Strategic Brand Storytelling
• Strategic Philanthropy
• Sustainable Urban Planning
• Symbolism in Art
• Tax Planning and Administration
• Technology and Policy
• The COMunicator
• The Congress
• The Craft of Writing: Film Focus
• The Modern Period
• The Social, Political, and Ethical Environment of Business
• Theater for Social Change
• Theories of International Relations
• Trauma Journalism
• Understanding Media
• Understanding Social Change and Issues of Race and Gender
• Visual Storytelling
• Women and Politics
• World Geography
• Writing for Public Relations

© 2024 Fiveable Inc. All rights reserved.

Ap® and sat® are trademarks registered by the college board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse this website..