URL | URL Type | Description |
---|
| Publisher | UNSPECIFIED |
Repository Staff Only: item control page Landmarks —Millikan Measures the Electron’s ChargeLandmarks articles feature important papers from the archives of the Physical Review journals. Researchers now routinely isolate single electrons in quantum dots, but a century ago the state-of-the-art charge-trapping device was a droplet of clock oil. Robert Millikan’s oil drop experiment provided the first clear measurement of the fundamental electric charge and thus helped cement the notion that nature is “grainy” at the smallest level. The first results came out in 1910, but the seminal work was a 1913 paper in the Physical Review . Millikan reported a value for the fundamental electric charge that was within half a percent of today’s accepted value. The experiment helped earn Millikan a Nobel prize in 1923 but has been a source of some controversy over the years. J. J. Thomson discovered the electron in 1897 when he measured the charge-to-mass ratio for electrons in a beam. But the value of the charge and whether it was fundamental remained open questions. Thomson and others tried to measure an irreducible electric charge by looking at clouds of water droplets. Using various techniques, they estimated the smallest charge that a droplet could hold, but the results were not entirely convincing because they relied on averages over many particles of various sizes. “The evidence for a unitary charge was at the time very ambiguous,” says science historian Gerald Holton of Harvard University. At the University of Chicago in the 1900s, Millikan and his graduate students realized that ramping up the electric field would disperse a water cloud, so that only a few droplets remained. He decided to try isolating single droplets, but it soon became clear that single water droplets evaporated too quickly to make reliable measurements. One of his students, Harvey Fletcher, found that long-lasting droplets could be made with a light oil that was used for lubricating clocks. The oil drop experiment that Millikan and Fletcher designed had two chambers. In the upper chamber, an atomizer (like that used in perfume bottles) dispersed a fine mist of micron-sized oil droplets. Individual droplets would fall through a pinhole into the lower chamber, which consisted of two horizontal plates, with one held 16 millimeters above the other. The air in this chamber was ionized with x rays , so that ions or free electrons could be captured on the falling droplets. A small window on the side allowed the scientists to observe the droplets through a telescope. The droplets fell slowly enough—due to atmospheric drag—that the researchers could measure their downward speed by eye, using horizontal lines in the telescope. From this speed, they could estimate the size and mass of each droplet. They then applied a high voltage across the plates and measured the upward speed of the droplet, to determine the electric force and ultimately the charge. Multiple measurements on a single droplet could be performed by repeatedly turning the electric field on and off. The droplets had various amounts of charge on them (and they would often gain or lose charge during an observation), but the data showed that the charge was indeed quantized into integer multiples of a unit charge. In 1910 Millikan published the first results of these experiments [1] (Fletcher was not included as an author, based on a deal the two struck [2] ). Millikan then made several improvements, including an empirical estimate of the drag forces. The culmination of this effort, reported in 1913, was a value of the fundamental charge with an error bar of just 0.2 percent. The precision acquired was so great that “other experiments did not improve on his result until a decade later,” Holton says. But Felix Ehrenhaft of the University of Vienna repeatedly challenged Millikan’s results, based on his own measurements of “sub-electron” charges on small metal particles. The dispute lasted for many years—known as the “Battle over the Electron”—but eventually most physicists sided with Millikan. In more recent years, historians who have examined Millikan’s lab notes have said that he discarded some of the measurements to boost the evidence of a fundamental charge. But David Goodstein of the California Institute of Technology in Pasadena believes these accusations of fraud are unwarranted. He has analyzed the notes and says that Millikan excluded droplets because their observations were incomplete, not because their implied charge didn’t match his expectations [3] . “Millikan’s oil drop experiment is a classic example of outstanding physics done by one of the giants of his era,” Goodstein says. –Michael Schirber Michael Schirber is a Corresponding Editor for Physics Magazine based in Lyon, France. - R. A. Millikan, “The Isolation of an Ion, a Precision Measurement of its Charge, and the Correction of Stokes’s Law,” Science 32 , 436 (1910) ; first reported at the American Physical Society meeting, 23 April 1910, Phys. Rev. (Series I) 30 , 656 (1910)
- H. Fletcher, “My work with Millikan on the oil‐drop experiment,” Phys. Today 35 , 43 (1982)
- D. Goodstein, “In Defense of Robert Andrews Millikan,” Am. Sci. 89 , 54 (2001)
More InformationFocus story on Millikan’s measurement of Planck’s constant article by Gerald Holton on the Millikan-Ehrenhaft Dispute article about the ethics of Millikan’s handling of data Millikan Nobel Prize: Nobel lecture, biography, and other information On the Elementary Electrical Charge and the Avogadro ConstantR. A. Millikan. Phys. Rev. 2 , 109 (1913) Published August 1, 1913 Subject AreasRelated articles. Deriving Fundamental Constants from Three-Beam CollisionsA proposed experiment involving an x-ray beam and two optical beams could determine the values of fundamental constants in quantum electrodynamics. Read More » Signatures of Gravitational Atoms from Black Hole MergersGravitational-wave signals from black hole mergers could reveal the presence of “gravitational atoms”—black holes surrounded by clouds of axions or other light bosons. Read More » Gamma-Ray Burst Tightens Constraints on Quantum GravityAn analysis of the brightest gamma-ray burst ever observed reveals no difference in the propagation speed of different frequencies of light—placing some of the tightest constraints on certain violations of general relativity. Read More » Sign up to receive weekly email alerts from Physics Magazine . |
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
Learn how Robert Millikan measured the electric charge of a single electron using an oil-drop experiment. Find out the results, the method, and the significance of this landmark discovery in physics.
Robert A. Millikan and Harvey Fletcher performed the oil drop experiment in 1909 to measure the elementary electric charge of the electron. They used a capacitor with oil droplets charged by x-rays and adjusted the electric field until the droplets were suspended.
Learn how Robert Millikan measured the charge of an electron using oil droplets and an electric field. Find out the apparatus, procedure, calculation and conclusion of the experiment, and test your knowledge with a quiz.
Learn how Robert Millikan and Harvey Fletcher measured the electric charge of the electron by observing charged oil droplets in free fall and an electric field. The experiment involved calculating the droplet radius and charge from the terminal velocities and the electric field strength.
Learn how Millikan measured the fundamental unit of electric charge using oil drops in 1913, and why his results were challenged and questioned by some scientists. Explore the historical and scientific context of his Nobel Prize-winning work and the allegations of scientific misconduct.
Learn how Robert Millikan and Harvey Fletcher measured the electric charge of an electron using oil drops and a uniform electric field. Find out the theory, calculations, conclusions and controversies of this classic experiment that proved the quantization of charge.
Robert Millikan was a US physicist who determined the magnitude of the electron's charge by measuring the motion of oil drops. He also worked on the photoelectric effect and helped establish Caltech as a leading physics institution.
Robert Millikan's experiment used oil droplets charged by friction or radiation to measure the charge of the electron. The oil droplets were suspended between two metal plates and their terminal velocity was measured as the voltage was varied.
The Millikan Oil Drop Experiment is a method of measuring the electric charge of a single electron by balancing the electrostatic and gravitational forces on an oil droplet. The experiment directly determined the charge of an electron to be 1.602×10−19 Coulombs.
The Oil Drop Experiment. In 1909, Robert Millikan and Harvey Fletcher conducted the oil drop experiment to determine the charge of an electron. They suspended tiny charged droplets of oil between two metal electrodes by balancing downward gravitational force with upward drag and electric forces. The density of the oil was known, so Millikan and ...
Learn how to measure the charge of an electron using oil droplets and a radioactive source in this classic physics experiment. Follow the theory, procedure, data analysis and conclusions of Robert Millikan, the Nobel Prize winner who performed this experiment in 1911.
Learn how Robert Millikan measured the charge on oil drops by observing their fall and rise times in an electric field. Find out how he deduced the quantisation of charge and the importance of his Nobel prize winning experiment.
Learn how to measure the elementary charge e using an oil drop and a capacitor. See the simulation, the calculation and the diagram of oil charges.
A document that explains the setup and procedure of Millikan's experiment to measure the charge of oil drops and determine the mass of electron. It includes background information, equations, instructions, and a table for recording data.
This video covers the famous Millikan experiment, determining the charge of an electron. Done in collaboration with Simon Crook (Crooked Science) and Tom Gor...
Learn how Robert Millikan measured the charge of an electron using oil droplets and an electric field. Find out the procedure, principles, importance and calculations of this famous physics experiment.
Learn how Robert Millikan and his student Harvey Fletcher used oil droplets to measure the fundamental electric charge in 1913, and how their work resolved the controversy over the nature of charge. The article also discusses the challenges and controversies of Millikan's experiment and its impact on physics.
This chemistry video for Grade 10-11 students demonstrates R. A. Millikan's oil drop experiment to calculate the charge of an electron.
his results. The experimental apparatus is shown in Figure 1. Millikan allowed a single. oil drop to fall a known distance in air. Millikan did not measure the time of fall from. rest, but allowed ...
For this work, and for work on the photoelectric effect, Millikan was awarded the Nobel Prize in physics in 1923. Millikan gives his own account of the electron charge determination in his published autobiography in the chapter titled "My Oil-Drop Venture (e)" (Robert A. Millikan, The Autobiography of Robert A. Millikan, New York, 1950).
Fletcher's work in the celebrated oil-drop experiment for which his thesis adviser, Rob-ert A. Millikan, won the Nobel Prize in 1923. Fletcher had instructed Gardner to publish the manuscript only posthumously, so it would be clear that Fletcher had no personal interest motivating its publication. In fact, Gardner told
The Millikan oil drop experiment, published in final form in 1913, demonstrated that charge comes in discrete chunks and was a bridge between classical electromagnetism and modern quantum physics. ... The first results came out in 1910, but the seminal work was a 1913 paper in the Physical Review. Millikan reported a value for the fundamental ...